Tyder, Tyder, I know you read my post to you about your disenchantment with the UFO stuff, and you were encouraged to delve deeper into the rabbit hole by others, but I pleaded with you to hang tight to your very accurate appraisal of your fatigue on the subject.
I just want to encourage you to have fun down there with Alice and the Mad Hatter, but I must appeal to that rationality I know you have and which is admirably reflected in your posts on this thread. Keep a very good grip on that malaise and weariness, and harken, Tdyer, to its small voice.
Now, of course, von Daniken was more than a bit off his rocker. So was Sitchin and others of his ilk in that ancient astronaut genre, and likewise is this Tsoukalos fellow. For entertainment, yes, but as bad apples infecting the whole barrel of reasoned thought, they should be discarded promptly. As an aside, I can barely stomach these TV shows that push all this stuff. There's the ominous music where needed, the lightening fast cuts, the cut and paste, faster and faster these frothing and foaming experts try to drag you deeper. For me, a good book by a reputable scientist, philosopher, theologian, etc., and there are mixtures of these things in many, many reputable scientists with hard credentials, is far more enlightening and far, far more truthful. I mean, at some point, an educated person has to come to some conclusions.
Great clip, Tyder, and I enjoyed watching it, by the way.
I see you have subscribed to the ancient humans explanation for these phenomena others attribute to ancient aliens. You are very correct.
However, don't let yourself be dragged deeper in that hole, Tyder, and it appears you are holding fast, by such statements as:
"The Ancient Human theory seems more probable to me." You and I agree, I think, Tyder with this statement. However:
Civilizations SEEM to have risen and fallen innumerable times on this planet." Capitals mine. Well, civilizations, kingdoms, societies, groups, dukedoms, republics, principalities, etc., etc. certainly have risen and then ended. But, it seems we're going deeper into that hole with "incredible natural and perhaps artificial disasters contributing to their destruction or regression." I beg for more specificity here, in terms of which civilizations have done so in which specific natural and artificial disasters.
The above request may be able to be answered somewhat, but I fear it will be a round peg in a square hole to meet the full request about which civilizations and which disasters specifically.
And then, there seems to be further subterranean progress down that hole with more statements of, well, what? "We could have left the planet already only to lose it all." I ask for specifics indeed.
And then, "Are there pockets of ancient humans or whatever they were (or their machines) still existing in remote, deep, or off-planet areas that could account for the UFO phenomena?" I cry, beg, plead, scream, whine, and, very curiously, too, ask for specifics, specifics, and more specifics.
"We could have left the planet already only to lose it all." Don't get this one at all.
And, "You need to realize how precarious technology actually is. All you need to do is loose (sic) a generation or two of engineers then you start over."
This happened? When? How? Where? Specifics needed desperately.
And all this "Ancient Human theory," all this speculation, "requires fewer assumptions and presents fewer logistical problems." The premise itself, based on high tech, machines, and still surviving in niches somewhere on this planet or off, need specifics and more specifics, and then that premise furthermore is easier to swallow because it requires fewer assumptions and fewer LOGISTICAL problems? Capitals mine, and provide those assumptions and logistics.
Now, all this Ancient Human theory is buttressed not with specifics as to who, what, when, where, and how, but is laid out quite matter of factly in a way that causes me to ask, in great curiosity, for those specifics. But it is then seemingly disqualified with "it's just a speculative question, mind you." No, no, not fair.
Are my seven years of college, and thirty five years of teaching history, all for naught because I cannot find these ancient humans who rose and fell due to natural and artificial disasters and perhaps are hidden off-planet or in pockets, well, I can be forgiven to ask again for specifics for these civilizations. Kim