Have you seen one like this before?
This is a genuine lobster and the picture is not doctored.
The reason I asked about the colour was because generally the colour of a "shellfish" is different before and after cooking, but there are some that are naturally red, like the ones in the picture in my first post.
When you said you ate some of the ones in the picture, it made me think about how "shellfish" is described on menus and packaging, for example shrimps, prawns, and crayfish*. It is very different to the way that "meat" for human consumption** is described, I for one would be very suspicious if I saw a dish described as for example "grass eating animal stew".
In short when it comes to meat we expect to know what species we will be consuming, but when it comes to "fish" we don't have the same expectation.
A good example is the Fillet-O-Fish from Mcdonalds, most people who eat them would not know when asked: what type of fish is used? (currently pollock but it has changed over the years)
The thing I find to be most ironic, is that the consumption and use of body parts from wild animals like Tigers, Rhinos, Gorillas and Elephants is seen as morally wrong in the "western World" but when it comes to the wild animals of the Sea (except Whales) they do not benefit from the same moral protection, that is to say if my local supermarket started selling Tiger stakes there would be uproar, yet I can go today and buy fresh or tinned
endangered Fish taken from the "wild" no questions asked.
Just to be clear I think that eating or using parts of endangered creatures of any kind is wrong Fishes included.
Finally my understanding is that the Whales are not counted among the Fishes for historical financial reasons, rather than the fact that they breathe air.
The change in their classification was due to a dispute over taxes incurred by a whaler, who did not want to pay the levy on "Fish oil" that was due, so he went to court and argued that a whale is not a fish, and therefor exempt from "fish oil Tax".
In my strange little world I include the whales and dolphins among the fishes for a number of reasons but I will not bore you any further.
*I think you call these crawfish or crawdaddys in the US
** pet food can sometimes be labeled as containing meat and fish derivatives