I am wondering if down the line the
Paracast could host both Carrion and Randle for a show specifically on this question alone. Leave out Carrion's
Rosetta Deception /
Ghost Rockets theory, and his theory of the Arnold sighting, and stay focused on details of Roswell for the whole show. I'm a bystanding observer and only recently started following the UFO field. But I did serve six years in the military in the '70's-'80's and I had a TS clearance for F-4 Phantom radar. Recently I searched around Dr. Randle's blog for a Roswell timeline to become familiar with that story and found this helpful post.
A Different Perspective: The Roswell Time Line - July 8, 1947
As I read it, together with comments, it occured to me that Blanchard's order for publicity of the "capture" of a disc had to have been calculated, probably for c
ounter intel, and that it was not a
drooling idiot SNAFU. I reached this conclusion before I'd even heard of James Carrion, and before I knew that he had reached the same conclusion several years ago. The 1952 movie
Above and Beyond dramatizes the stifling security the 509th operated under. Then too, had Tibbets been unable to fly the Hiroshima strike, Blanchard was his backup (if I am not mistaken) and he would have led it. In other words, Blanchard was in the middle of all the intense security dramatized in
Above and Beyond. So, agreeing with Carrion on this issue, it is difficult to believe Blanchard would order immediate publicity of something that so easily could have been kept quiet, unless it was an intel operation. Soviets agents were surely acquiring US nuclear secrets by any means, but US info on their activity had decreased after 1945. Roswell might have been an operation to shake something loose. The Soviets detonated their A-bomb in 1949. And, incidentally, in the summer of 1947 the first Soviet rivet-for-rivet back-engineered copy of the B-29 (Tu-4) was flown. Publicity of a US B-29 unit's capture of an advanced aerial vehicle amenable to back-engineering might possibly have been done to demoralize the Soviets, in addition to shaking the tree.
A real debris field of advanced metal alloys (human manufactured) could have been planted in that desolate rural NM field, just waiting for Brazel. Only a few officers of the 509th staff would have had to know it was planted. Everyone else could believe it was a real "disc" and would have kept their mouths shut, pretty much. In my opinion this operation would only work if intelligence agencies, East and West, had concluded that inexplicable phenomena (foo fighters / ghost rockets) were occuring and that they were intelligently controlled and probably of non-human origin. I have no iron in the fire for any Roswell solution, whether misidentified weather balloon, mogul balloon, alien crash or intel operation. But an intel operation does make sense of Blanchard's order for publicity, followed by the subsequent scramble to shut the story down.
IMHO it would make a fascinating
Paracast if Carrion and Randle would agree to weigh the Roswell evidence together with you guys, Gene and Chris.
Best wishes.