Jeff Davis
Paranormal Adept
Well we've also seen self-organization in matter, so by what criterion do we separate self-organization in matter from organization by consciousness? It would appear that (unfortunately for consciousness--loosely speaking) we either use a criteria based on our own conscious grasp of the situation regarding the imprint of "matter" (or the idea of matter which we are unable to sometimes distinguish) or we throw it out and talk about material things as if the very idea of their existence had some meaning in the scheme of things. Both positions are untenable due to the very (probably false) assumption that they are independent. So when you say "demonstrable" what I hear is "demonstrable within a consciousness-matter dichotomy system" Consciousness applies some kind of intended force to matter and then adjusts its understanding by the response, however is unable to see it own self-organizing roots. This limitation cannot be explicated in the consciouness-matter dualism, as the consciousness (read: spirit) strives to make everything material (which is an idea or concept) for consciousness. How else do we see "self-organizing" behavior other than some mysterious "hidden hand" or "intelligence" that seems to pervade the self-organized system? We instantly apply intentionality to it because we ourselves do not have the cognitive framework to think otherwise. What we have is some kind of "intentionality" prejudice that prevents us from making clear the criterion above (self-organized matter vs consciousness organized matter) -- in fact the harder we try to make that criterion explicit, the further and further consciousness itself blends into the very landscape of its background: matter.
My solution is to dispense with the dualism from the start and let the questions evaporate.
I have read only a surface level smattering of what is proposed as self organizational within nature. So I really cannot pretend to do it justice. The problem with what is being deemed self organizational (in some/not all cases hence my lack of familiarity) is that it's classified as such post observation. When I state demonstrable I am referring to the repeatable/verifiable lab controlled measurements of electron activity post and minus observation per their consistently predictable behavior and/or organizational patterns. Observation of course representing sentient awareness/consciousness.