Well, try this then:
“My war brought me many things; let yours bring you as much. Life is not to be told, call it as loud as you like, it will not tell itself. No one will be much or little except in someone else's mind, so be careful of the minds you get into, and remember Lady Macbeth, who had her mind in her hand. We can't all be as safe as that.” / Djuna Barnes
Tried it, still not sure what you mean. Probably have better results if you just speak in a straight forward manner.
As for alcohol and violence we know that 40% of all crime in the US involves alcohol [and the rest of your stats]
There are so many problems with this:
1. Do we? I don't know that. You might think you do, but unless you actually supply a source that shows this to be true in a reliable and convincing manner, let's leave this out of the discussion, since unsubstantiated claims are worthless.
2. 100% of crimes "involved" a person. 100% of crimes "involved" oxygen. 100% of crimes "involved" the space-time continuum. Therefore each is of these three things is "mostly about violence, dude." Hopefully it's enough to just state this for you to realize how flawed the logic is.
3. It's irrelevant how many crimes involved alcohol, if you're trying to prove what alcohol is "mostly" about. Show how many drunk people committed a crime, not how many criminals are drunks.
4. Not all crime is violent.
5. Even if we granted that alcohol mainly causes violence, and most violence is caused by alcohol, it still wouldn't make any sense to ban alcohol, since violence is *already* illegal.
There are more problems with your logic, I'm sure, but hopefully these will do.
But a more important question, Duncan, what exactly are you trying to prove, that Macbeth was right to listen to his Lady?
Nothing. Yours was the claim, I only asked about it. The onus of proof is on you.
Is there really anything here to win?
A great deal. When someone has a wildly crazy view, and I ask them about it, I either get to find out that their view isn't wildly cazy at all, or I get to be even more sure that it's wildly crazy by having them try to support it. This is a win-win.