@Realm, I'm wondering what you are hoping to prove with these extended searches for discrepancies in the reporting available to date re the 2004 Nimitz events. Do you think that the information presented so far suggests a plot of some kind, involving various branches of the US government, military, and intelligence agencies, to fake us all out? And if so, to what end?
Hope you don't mind my asking.
No, I don't mind at all. I'm glad you asked.
I'm simply trying to extract as much information I can from the limited amount we have, in hopes of getting a better picture of what actually happened and which information is accurate. That includes doing what the so called debunkers do, that is, trying to find discrepancies, just without the preconceived assumptions about the end results, and actually trying to find explanations for them as well. I'm really trying to take as objective and scientific look at it that I can, because I don't want to believe, I want to know, as much as possible.
I see this case as a rather special one: multiple witnesses who are trained observers, bright daylight, video, radar returns, military event log that looks authentic, reported UFO capabilities seem beyond any tech I would expect from any nation, Pentagon insider who probably investigated it, both that insider and witnesses basically being convinced and stating publicly it was aliens, a lot of media visibility and people taking it seriously, no indication of it being a hoax or something similar, and most of all, a story that hasn't fallen apart yet despite all this poking.
It's the kind of thing I have been hoping to see someday at least since O'Hare, which also received considerable media attention and happened already 11 years ago (and coincidentally, they happened pretty much exactly 2 years apart, especially if they were seeing those radar returns for a week or more). That one left me with a sentiment similar to that described here:
[Mark] Rodeghier: The whole 2006 thing was a travesty from the word go. The (Federal Aviation Administration) should have looked into it, but they just blew it off. I can't explain why there aren't any photos or videos of it. This is one of the mysteries around UFOs, but there's more than enough witness testimony. I'm convinced something was there, but you wind up with a mystery, though you certainly can't say it's alien because you don't have all the information. That's what's so important about the acknowledgment of this government program. We want to see the data and reports from this program released to the public if it's not a national security issue. If the program has been defunded, let's see what you did and what we got for $22 million.
'Something was there:' Chicago expert on O'Hare UFO, government program
Clearly this is a case that needs to be taken seriously and should be investigated properly, but I don't know if that has been done, and I don't think the media is doing it properly. So I'm trying to do it myself to the extent I can. It's not about trying to convince others in one way or another, but just to extract as much information as possible. And I think it is a bit of race against time in the sense that all this attention won't last long, so if there are issues that could be clarified or questions to be asked, now is the time to try to find someone who could answer or ask from those who could.
Since I don't expect we can get that much additional concrete evidence from this case (we can hope for better quality FLIR with a few extra seconds, possibly some gun camera footage, radar data probably stays off limits), it becomes a matter of who and which information you can trust. Based on all that I have seen so far, I think this event happened, the log and video are authentic, Fravor and Slaight are talking about it honestly, but they don't remember all the details correctly anymore. I haven't seen any indication of some wider conspiracy or anything like that, although obviously information is being withheld. I also don't think this is part of some organized campaign to release information (or disinformation, or some major disclosure some are hoping for), as after all, most of it has already leaked years ago in a rather uncontrolled manner. I also think cases like this might even be all the government/military has, and that we can't count on something better will come in the future, so I don't want this to become just another missed opportunity.
And no, I'm not saying it had to be aliens, but since I honestly don't have any better explanation for it that would be based on actual facts or arguments I could justify, I have to say that is a real possibility.