I think this is another area where the context is important, and can also be a bit elusive to folks just coming upon the stuff. I was hoping Carpenter would make the specific point that the vast majority of Stringfield's material was gathered well before the late 80s, but I don't think he ever did. Back then, when someone like Stringfield had soldiers and government employees giving him reports that dovetailed well with the abduction research he was aware of, that was a powerful corroboration. Not many people knew anything about either subject. In fact, it can be very useful to divide the public side of ufology into the categories of "before
Intruders and
Communion" and "after those books." Everything changed in the late 80s, and not just because of those books, but they make a handy reference point. Of course he was aware of the disinformation and other nonsense polluting the field, and he wrote about it. He was no dummy, by any means.
Another thing that looks a lot different to us now is the idea that "
They may just be about to spill the beans. Might be any day now." The whole subject of UFOs was younger than most of the people involved in it, and such statements were nowhere near as tedious as they have become in the last 25 years.
I've been looking around the web, and can't find Stringfield's "Status Reports" anywhere except archived at Earthfiles. You can pay $40 and fish dozens of documents out of all the... other stuff there, and then reassemble the reports. They were posted over about a two year period, in reverse order but in parts that were posted in order. It was a bit annoying to read them that way as they showed up over those months, (Stringfield often referenced earlier reports, which of course had not appeared on Earthfiles yet) but now they are scattered in with other documents that sometimes have similar names. It's not much fun. For your $40 you also can access Stringfield's book,
Inside Saucer Post 3-0 Blue in something like 12 installments, along with a lot of stuff about Jim Sparks.
If anyone knows where that stuff can be found, I'd love to hear about it. I consider it a valuable record of some things that never were very well known, and I'd like to read it again.