Burnt State
Paranormal Adept
Forgive me, but what is "magical thinking"?...
I agree about the religious aspects of these matters. People that simply have adopted space brethren philosophies as fact of the matter are not adopting anything less than a religion for themselves. However, if I had a nickle for every individual who's life was basically turned upside down by the AAP, who also have in no way sought monetary compensation or attention, we could most likely throw one hell of a paracast bash for the next year straight. This is a little more serious than some farmer claiming a pancake breakfast with aliens here. This AAP happens to people from every walk of life and nearly every profession conceivable. Some of these claimed abductees are some really distinguished people with a great deal to lose.
Something *is* happening. What that something is, I don't know but I have a hard time with "the people are just making it all up". I don't think so.
I like to think of 'magical thinking' as creative thought, things sparking from the imaginative well and ultimately responsible for our artistic endeavors. However in the world of alien abductions it has a different definition as seen in Susan Clancy's text How People Come To Believe They we're Kidnapped by Aliens. In there she says of the commonalities in AAP subjects: They are certainly, with an exception or two, not “crazy,” as so many first suspect upon hearing their tales. They are, however, more imaginative, creative, and fantasy-prone than the general population. They also score higher on a trait called schizotypy. This does not mean that they are schizophrenic, but “they're generally a bit odd. They tend to look and think eccentrically and are prone to 'magical' thinking and odd beliefs”
So, yes, we can say something is taking place but most likely it is only taking place in the minds of the 'experiencer' and most likely is something that happened: in a dream space, through sleep paralysis, has been frequently an outright hoax, has been demonstrated to be a mask for actual traumatic events such as severe abuse, sexual assault & incest etc.. Some people are looking for attention, even negative attention, and may not want the fame and glory synonymous with most of the hoaxers, but may have some self-esteem issues that requires them to seek out any attention that deals with their own masochism.
I don't think it's always as simple as people making it all up, but one audio listen to Derril Sims on The Aracast shows you how quickly, in the name of therapy, so-called researchers have not only pushed their children into the space of AAP, but irresponsible hypnosis, even with those people who identified issues of sexual assault are still being given 'therapy' by a man who has no clinicl training to treat such people, yet he is still labeling them as victims of alien abduction.
At the end of the day there is a small handful of cases that only come marginally close to allusions towards alien abduction - lots of words, but no proof. Even worse are the many profile investigators who have made a living out of 'proving' in the minds of the public, that AAP is real. Between Mack's peace and light aliens and Hopkins' evil alien kidnappers there's a lot of shenanigans going on, but that's about it.
What are the good cases for alien abduction?